| Player | Year | Position | School |
| Ashley Marble | 2001-02 | OH | Woodland HS |
| Katie Holmes | 2001-02 | MB | Woodland HS |
| Katie Holmes | 2002-03 | MB | Woodland HS |
| Kelsy Snowman | 2003-04 | S | Woodland HS |
| Bethany Carle | 2004-05 | OH | Greely HS |
| Michelle Ferry | 2005-06 | OH | Woodland HS |
| Mariah Grover | 2006-07 | MH | MDI HS |
| Mariah Grover | 2007-08 | MB | MDI HS |
| Michaela Campbell | 2008-09 | OH | Greely HS |
| Michaela Campbell | 2009-10 | OH | Greely HS |
| Keila Grigware | 2010-11 | OH | Biddeford HS |
| Brittany Bona | 2011-12 | OH | Scarborough HS |
| Mariah Hebert | 2012-13 | S | Biddeford HS |
| Katrina Meserve | 2013-14 | OH | Falmouth HS |
| Sarah Shelton | 2014-15 | OH | Ellsworth HS |
